UN: Trust Is Running Out, Reforms Cannot Wait
Context: Created in 1945 after World War II to prevent another global war and promote peace, cooperation and human rights, the United Nations today faces questions about its effectiveness due to conflicts, Security Council deadlock and inadequate representation.
Original Purpose & Structural Mismatch
Maintain international peace and security through collective action and peaceful dispute settlement; the Security Council holds primary responsibility under Article 24 of the UN Charter.
Permanent Security Council membership still reflects the post-World War II power structure, even as new centres of economic/political influence have emerged with limited representation.
Why the UN Is Losing Trust
Veto power of the five permanent members can block collective action; Africa has no permanent seat, and countries like India remain outside permanent membership.
Resolutions don't always translate into ground action; delayed member contributions have affected the UN's functioning, widening the gap between mandate and capacity.
Reform Agenda & India's Stake
Expand Security Council representation; encourage voluntary veto restraint in mass-atrocity situations; move to text-based negotiations; implement the UN80 Initiative for administrative efficiency; ensure timely payment of assessed contributions.
Seeks permanent Security Council membership in a reformed UN, citing population, global role, peacekeeping contributions and representation of developing countries — aiming for a representative, effective, rules-based order.
Prelims Practice MCQ
+2 correct • −0.66 wrongConsider the following statements:
1. The Security Council's primary responsibility for international peace and security is provided under Article 24 of the UN Charter.
2. Africa currently holds a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.
3. The UN80 Initiative is aimed at improving administrative efficiency and reducing duplication within the UN system.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
UPSC Mains Question
10 Marks • 150 WordsDiscuss the structural challenges facing the United Nations and examine the reforms needed to restore its credibility and effectiveness, with reference to India's stake in this process.
- Cite Article 24 of the UN Charter precisely as the legal basis for the Security Council's primary responsibility.
- Name the specific reform proposals — expanded representation, voluntary veto restraint, text-based negotiations, UN80 Initiative — individually.
- Note Africa's lack of a permanent seat explicitly as the clearest evidence of the representation deficit.
- Frame India's Security Council case on four grounds — population, global role, peacekeeping contribution, developing-country representation.
- Emphasise the core principle that administrative efficiency (UN80) must be paired with political/structural reform, not substitute for it.
