About the 229th Law Commission Report, 2009
- Title: “Need for division of the Supreme Court into a Constitution Bench at Delhi and Cassation Benches in four regions at Delhi, Chennai/Hyderabad, Kolkata and Mumbai”.
- Submitted: August 2009 by the 18th Law Commission, chaired by Justice A.R. Lakshmanan.
Key Recommendations
- Constitution Bench at Delhi: to deal only with constitutional and allied issues.
- Four Cassation Benches: for regular appellate work (civil, criminal, labour, tax and so on). Located in the North (Delhi), South (Chennai or Hyderabad), East (Kolkata) and West (Mumbai).
- Rationale:
- reduce pendency;
- cut the cost and distance burden on litigants;
- free the Supreme Court to function as a true constitutional court.
- Method: can be done under Article 130, or by a law enacted by Parliament.
Earlier and Later Recommendations
- 95th Law Commission Report (1984): split the Supreme Court into a Constitutional Division and a Legal Division.
- 125th Law Commission Report (1988): reiterated the need for division.
- Parliamentary Standing Committee on Law and Justice: recommended regional benches in several reports, including in 2023-24.
- National Court of Appeal: suggested in Bihar Legal Support Society (1986) and considered in V. Vasanthakumar (2016). Former AG K.K. Venugopal proposed four regional Courts of Appeal.
Global Comparison
- United States: the Supreme Court hears only about 60-70 cases a year; Circuit Courts of Appeal handle most appeals.
- United Kingdom: the Supreme Court hears a limited number of cases of public importance.
- France, Italy: separate Courts of Cassation for appeals, distinct from constitutional courts.
Status
- Not implemented. The Supreme Court’s Full Court did not favour regional benches (2010), and successive governments have deferred to the judiciary on the matter.
- Renewed debate in 2026: the rise in judge strength to 38 and record pendency have revived the idea. Critics argue that more judges alone cannot fix the Court’s structural problem of being both a constitutional court and a general court of appeal.
Way Forward
- Consensus between the judiciary, executive and Parliament on a structural reform.
- A pilot of regional benches for specific categories of appeals.
- Strengthen High Courts and fill vacancies (about one in four High Court posts was vacant in early 2026).
- Use of technology, case management and mediation to reduce inflow.
229th Law Commission Report, 2009