Batch 2 Starts 16 Nov: Admissions Open! Enroll Now

229th Law Commission Report, 2009

About the 229th Law Commission Report, 2009

  • Title: “Need for division of the Supreme Court into a Constitution Bench at Delhi and Cassation Benches in four regions at Delhi, Chennai/Hyderabad, Kolkata and Mumbai”.
  • Submitted: August 2009 by the 18th Law Commission, chaired by Justice A.R. Lakshmanan.

Key Recommendations

  • Constitution Bench at Delhi: to deal only with constitutional and allied issues.
  • Four Cassation Benches: for regular appellate work (civil, criminal, labour, tax and so on). Located in the North (Delhi), South (Chennai or Hyderabad), East (Kolkata) and West (Mumbai).
  • Rationale:
    • reduce pendency;
    • cut the cost and distance burden on litigants;
    • free the Supreme Court to function as a true constitutional court.
  • Method: can be done under Article 130, or by a law enacted by Parliament.

Earlier and Later Recommendations

  • 95th Law Commission Report (1984): split the Supreme Court into a Constitutional Division and a Legal Division.
  • 125th Law Commission Report (1988): reiterated the need for division.
  • Parliamentary Standing Committee on Law and Justice: recommended regional benches in several reports, including in 2023-24.
  • National Court of Appeal: suggested in Bihar Legal Support Society (1986) and considered in V. Vasanthakumar (2016). Former AG K.K. Venugopal proposed four regional Courts of Appeal.

Global Comparison

  • United States: the Supreme Court hears only about 60-70 cases a year; Circuit Courts of Appeal handle most appeals.
  • United Kingdom: the Supreme Court hears a limited number of cases of public importance.
  • France, Italy: separate Courts of Cassation for appeals, distinct from constitutional courts.

Status

  • Not implemented. The Supreme Court’s Full Court did not favour regional benches (2010), and successive governments have deferred to the judiciary on the matter.
  • Renewed debate in 2026: the rise in judge strength to 38 and record pendency have revived the idea. Critics argue that more judges alone cannot fix the Court’s structural problem of being both a constitutional court and a general court of appeal.

Way Forward

  • Consensus between the judiciary, executive and Parliament on a structural reform.
  • A pilot of regional benches for specific categories of appeals.
  • Strengthen High Courts and fill vacancies (about one in four High Court posts was vacant in early 2026).
  • Use of technology, case management and mediation to reduce inflow.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

229th Law Commission Report, 2009

Got a question? We're here to help!

Our dedicated Student Support team is ready to assist you and guide you every step of the way.
Reach out to us, and let’s tackle your queries together!

Copyright © 2026 USARAMBHA EDUCATION (UnderStand UPSC). All Rights Reserved.

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x